There’s no greater drama in soccer than World Cup penalty shootouts. Heroes are born, legends fall, and nations hold their breath. For some, it’s the ultimate glory. For others, it’s the cruelest way to exit the tournament. These 15 penalty shootouts are the most heart-stopping, gut-wrenching, and unforgettable moments in World Cup history.

1. Argentina vs. France – Final (2022)

After a 3-3 thriller, the final went to penalties. Argentina triumphed 4-2, with Emiliano Martínez’s mind games and Messi’s composure stealing the show.

2. Brazil vs. Italy – Final (1994)

The first World Cup final to be decided by penalties. Roberto Baggio’s infamous miss sealed Brazil’s fourth title in one of the tensest finishes in history.

3. Germany vs. England – Semifinal (1990)

A painful memory for England. The match ended 1-1, and Germany won 4-3 in the shootout. Paul Gascoigne’s tears and Stuart Pearce’s miss became iconic.

4. Italy vs. France – Final (2006)

Zidane’s headbutt overshadowed what became a tense shootout. Italy won 5-3, and Fabio Grosso scored the winning penalty in a legendary conclusion.

5. Croatia vs. Denmark – Round of 16 (2018)

After early goals, the match stayed 1-1. Both keepers made stunning saves in the shootout, but Croatia edged it 3-2 thanks to Luka Modrić’s leadership.

6. Spain vs. South Korea – Quarterfinal (2002)

Controversial officiating and a 0-0 stalemate led to penalties. South Korea won 5-3, sparking debate and wild celebrations.

7. Argentina vs. Netherlands – Semifinal (2014)

Goalless for 120 minutes. Argentina’s goalkeeper Sergio Romero became the hero, saving two penalties in a 4-2 shootout win.

8. England vs. Colombia – Round of 16 (2018)

England’s first-ever World Cup penalty shootout win. Jordan Pickford saved and Eric Dier scored the decisive penalty in a 4-3 win.

9. Russia vs. Spain – Round of 16 (2018)

After a 1-1 draw, Russia shocked the world by defeating Spain 4-3 on penalties. Igor Akinfeev’s heroic saves made headlines.

10. Germany vs. Argentina – Quarterfinal (2006)

It ended 1-1, and Jens Lehmann’s infamous cheat sheet helped Germany win 4-2. One of the smartest goalkeeping performances ever.

11. Portugal vs. England – Quarterfinal (2006)

Wayne Rooney’s red card and Cristiano Ronaldo’s wink set the stage. Portugal won 3-1 after England crumbled under pressure yet again.

12. Brazil vs. Chile – Round of 16 (2014)

Tied 1-1, this shootout saw Neymar convert and Júlio César save two penalties to rescue the hosts in front of a raucous Rio crowd.

13. Uruguay vs. Ghana – Quarterfinal (2010)

After Suárez’s infamous handball, Ghana missed the extra-time penalty. The shootout ended 4-2 in Uruguay’s favor—one of the most dramatic tie-breakers ever.

14. France vs. Italy – Quarterfinal (1998)

A defensive battle that ended 0-0. Italy missed a crucial spot-kick, and France advanced 4-3 on penalties en route to winning the tournament.

15. Sweden vs. Romania – Quarterfinal (1994)

After a 2-2 draw, Sweden advanced 5-4 in the shootout. Thomas Ravelli’s save sent Sweden to their first semifinal in decades.

Conclusion

Penalty shootouts are pure drama. They deliver heartbreak, elation, and stories that last for generations. From the agony of missed kicks to the ecstasy of last saves, these 15 tie-breakers prove why the World Cup is the most emotionally charged tournament in sports.

15 Most Heart-Stopping Tie-Breakers in World Cup Penalty Shootouts History

Keyword: World Cup penalty shootouts

Few moments in football carry as much tension as a World Cup penalty shootout. The entire world seems to pause as players step up to decide their nation’s fate. The World Cup penalty shootouts below capture the beauty and cruelty of the game — stories of redemption, heartbreak, and unshakable nerves. These 15 tie-breakers stand as the most heart-stopping moments in World Cup history.

1) Argentina vs. France – Final (2022)

In one of the greatest matches ever played, Argentina and France battled to a 3-3 draw before penalties decided the world champion (New York Times). Emiliano Martínez’s mind games and clutch saves broke French hearts, while Lionel Messi’s composure sealed his legacy. Argentina triumphed 4-2 in a finale that defined modern football drama.

2) Brazil vs. Italy – Final (1994)

It was the first World Cup Final ever decided by penalties, and it ended in agony for Italy (BBC). After a goalless draw, Roberto Baggio’s sky-high miss sealed Brazil’s fourth title. The image of Baggio’s heartbreak in Pasadena remains one of the most iconic in football history.

3) Germany vs. England – Semifinal (1990)

A defining moment in England’s penalty trauma. After a tense 1-1 draw, Germany won 4-3 in the shootout (The Guardian). Stuart Pearce and Chris Waddle missed, while Paul Gascoigne’s tears symbolized England’s heartbreak. It became one of the most emotional nights in World Cup history.

4) Italy vs. France – Final (2006)

The 2006 Final had everything — Zinedine Zidane’s headbutt, incredible tension, and a nail-biting shootout (FIFA). Fabio Grosso scored the decisive penalty as Italy triumphed 5-3. It was a fittingly dramatic end to one of football’s most memorable tournaments.

5) Croatia vs. Denmark – Round of 16 (2018)

After early goals, the game stayed locked at 1-1. The shootout turned into a battle of nerves, with both keepers saving spectacularly (Sports Illustrated). Croatia edged it 3-2, thanks to Luka Modrić’s leadership and Danijel Subašić’s heroics in goal.

6) Spain vs. South Korea – Quarterfinal (2002)

This was one of the most controversial matches in World Cup history (The Guardian). Spain had two goals disallowed before losing 5-3 on penalties to co-hosts South Korea. The officiating sparked outrage but also ignited unforgettable celebrations across Asia.

7) Argentina vs. Netherlands – Semifinal (2014)

Goalless after 120 minutes, Argentina advanced 4-2 on penalties (FIFA). Goalkeeper Sergio Romero became a national hero after saving two spot-kicks. His calm performance sent Argentina to the final — and Lionel Messi’s celebration said it all.

8) England vs. Colombia – Round of 16 (2018)

England finally broke their penalty curse (BBC). After a 1-1 draw, Jordan Pickford’s crucial save and Eric Dier’s winning kick sealed a 4-3 victory. The win ended decades of heartbreak and marked a new era for England under Gareth Southgate.

9) Russia vs. Spain – Round of 16 (2018)

Host nation Russia pulled off a monumental upset, defeating Spain 4-3 on penalties after a 1-1 draw (Reuters). Igor Akinfeev’s incredible double save became an instant classic. The Luzhniki Stadium erupted in disbelief and joy.

10) Germany vs. Argentina – Quarterfinal (2006)

This 1-1 thriller went to penalties, where Jens Lehmann used his famous “cheat sheet” to anticipate Argentina’s shots (Sports Illustrated). Germany won 4-2, and Lehmann’s preparation became part of World Cup folklore.

11) Portugal vs. England – Quarterfinal (2006)

Wayne Rooney’s red card left England shorthanded, and Cristiano Ronaldo’s wink added to the tension (The Guardian). Portugal held their nerve to win 3-1 in the shootout. For England, it was another heartbreak; for Ronaldo, another defining moment.

12) Brazil vs. Chile – Round of 16 (2014)

In front of an electric Rio crowd, Brazil and Chile battled to a 1-1 draw. Júlio César became the hero, saving two penalties, while Neymar sealed the 3-2 win (FIFA). It was Brazil’s narrowest escape — and one of their most emotional victories.

13) Uruguay vs. Ghana – Quarterfinal (2010)

Perhaps the most controversial shootout ever. After Luis Suárez’s last-minute handball stopped a certain goal, Ghana missed the extra-time penalty (BBC). Uruguay then won 4-2 in the shootout. The heartbreak was immense — Ghana came inches from becoming Africa’s first semifinalist.

14) France vs. Italy – Quarterfinal (1998)

Before meeting again in 2006, France and Italy clashed in a tight 1998 quarterfinal that ended 0-0 (UEFA). France won 4-3 on penalties, with Fabio Cannavaro’s miss proving decisive. The victory set Les Bleus on course for their first title.

15) Sweden vs. Romania – Quarterfinal (1994)

After an intense 2-2 draw, Sweden triumphed 5-4 in the shootout (Sports Illustrated). Goalkeeper Thomas Ravelli’s save sent his nation to its first semifinal in decades. The emotional celebrations remain one of the tournament’s purest moments of joy.

Conclusion

World Cup penalty shootouts embody football’s greatest paradox — triumph and tragedy at the same time. For every hero, there’s a heartbroken rival. From Martínez’s mind games to Baggio’s miss, these moments reveal football’s rawest emotions. And that’s why we keep watching — because no scriptwriter could invent drama this perfect.

Which World Cup had the most penalty shootouts?

The 2018 World Cup holds the record with four shootouts, showcasing how evenly matched modern football has become (FIFA).

Who is the most successful team in World Cup penalty shootouts?

Germany has historically been the most successful nation in shootouts, winning nearly all of them thanks to their composure and preparation (DW).

Suggested Internal Reads: 15 Bizarre and Unforgettable On-Pitch Incidents · 15 Statistical Oddities from 90+ Years of World Cup Matches · 15 Surprising Rules That Have Existed in Past World Cups